2 (January 2003), pp. Also finds that the presence of a written grievance procedure makes it less likely that unions will win the election. Also finds that the industries with higher premiums had larger decreases in union jobs. 35, No. Long, Richard J., "The Effect of Unionization on Employment Growth of Canadian Companies," Industrial and Labor Relations Review , Vol. 1 (April 2001), pp. Hirsch, Barry T., "Reconsidering Union Wage Effects: Surveying New Evidence on an Old Topic," Journal of Labor Research , Vol. In short, the empire of right to work leans toward further entrenching the power of corporations, not the economic emancipation of American wage earners. 3 (August 2001), pp. Bratsberg, Bernt, and James F. Ragan, Jr., "Changes in the Union Wage Premium by Industry," Industrial and Labor Relations Review , Vol. 24/7 Wall Street. You may have caught wind of what followed: widespread outrage from social conservatives, calls for boycotts of the beer by country stars and rappers (including Kid Rock, who released a video in which he destroyed cases of Bud Light with an assault weapon), a significant drop in Bud Lights sales in one week and the loss of about $5 billion in market capitalization. Finds that jobs grow 4 percentage points a year more slowly in unionized manufacturing and non-manufacturing firms than in comparable non-union firms. The emerging-markets bloc of Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa will meet in Cape Town on June 2-3 to discuss its enlargement, Anil Sooklal, South Africas ambassador to the group, said in an interview in the city on Monday. That lawyer was soon-to-be Supreme Court Justice Lewis F. Powell Jr., whose now-famous Powell Memorandum is a telling insight into the frustration that many business leaders felt by the early 1970s. The Detroit automakers have done so poorly in the recent economic downturn in part because they invested far less than their non-union competitors in researching and developing fuel-efficient vehicles. Whether or not the union is affiliated with the American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations (AFL-CIO) was also provided as supplemental data. 34-53. [29] Most studies show that jobs contract or grow more slowly, by between 3 and 4 percentage points a year, in unionized businesses than they do in non-unionized businesses. To discover the causal affect of organizing on wages, researchers compare wage changes at newly organized plants with wage changes at plants where organizing drives failed. Meanwhile, workers expectations had risen as a result of wartime gains, and they were not in a mood to give up those gains. My maternal grandfather, a toolmaker at Buick, would no more have allowed someone to drink Coors in his presence in defiance of a union boycott than he would have tolerated a foreign car parked in his driveway. Innovation in the form of assembly lines and mass production gave power to unskilled workers. Copyright 20102023, The Conversation US, Inc. Trump and Pence met with with local labor leaders and union members in Brook Park, Ohio, in September. April 29, 2023, 7:00 a.m. After a series of progressive presidencies, the playing field once again tilted toward employers. In response, over 3,500 work stoppages involving more than 4 million workers occurred in 1919. This was not always the case. Hirsch, Barry T., and Edward J. Schumacher, "Unions, Wages, and Skills," Journal of Human Resources , Vol. [3]Dr. Anne Layne-Farrar, "An Empirical Assessment of the Employee Free Choice Act: The Economic Implications," Law and Economics Consulting Group, March 3 2009, at http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm Economists would expect reduced investment, coupled with the intentional effort of the union cartel to reduce employment, to cause unions to reduce jobs in the companies they organize. Unions can raise wages only at companies that have competitive advantages that permit them to pay higher wages, such as successful R&D projects or long-lasting capital investments. 119, No. That February, labor unions across Seattle halted work in solidarity with 35,000 shipyard workers who had walked off the job in the first general (or cross-industry) strike in American history. Many deepened their commitments to politics. Both of these changes are highly controversial. 1 (January 1990), pp. 233-266. As heavily-unionized industries declined, non-skilled workers lost their bargaining power -- and the middle class lost its share of overall income. So long and to the extent that I can speak for the government of the United States, I will use the power of the government to prevent the labor unions of the country from destroying the open shop, he declared. 35-50. Just as importantly, it has historically not occurred in occupations that don't attract skilled labor. 1 (Winter 1998), pp. "The Rise and Fall of U.S. NAFTA affected U.S. workers in four principal ways. A new crop of leaders is trying to change that. In competitive markets, unions cannot cartelize labor and raise wages. Presents both theory and empirical evidence on the effect of unions on investment. [4]George Borjas, Labor Economics, 3rd edition (Columbus, Ohio: McGraw-Hill, 2005). BuzzFeed, Lyft, Whole Foods and Deloitte all recently announced layoffs affecting thousands of US workers. 349-354, at http://www.unionstats.com/ (May 5, 2009). Following the onset of the Great Depression, however, organized labor rebounded as President Franklin D. Roosevelt advanced his New Deal program, which brought new protections that led to a new surge in union membership. Monitor your investments 24 hours a day, around the clock from around the globe. Finds that union members are more similar than workers in non-union firms and naturally earn more similar wages. The number of jobs in unionized companies shrank by an average of 3 percent a year during that time, and the number of jobs in non-union companies grew by 3 percent a year. 233-266. Uses a survey of firms that underwent organizing drives and their closest competitors to estimate the effects of unionization on businesses. [27]Bernt Bratsberg and James F. Ragan, Jr., "Changes in the Union Wage Premium by Industry," Industrial and Labor Relations Review, Vol. 163-193. Nineteen countries expressed an interest in joining the BRICS group of nations as it prepares to hold an annual summit in South Africa. After World War I, however, the labor movement lost ground. I think they saw it as a necessary evil. 101, No. Imagine that General Motors, Ford, and Chrysler jointly agreed to raise the price of the cars they sold by $2,000: Their profits would rise as every American who bought a car paid more. First, robots replaced unskilled workers in factories. Jakubson, George, "Estimation and Testing of the Union Wage Effect Using Panel Data," Review of Economic Studies , Vol. All data was collected and up to date as of Sept. 11, 2019. Find History on Facebook (Opens in a new window), Find History on Twitter (Opens in a new window), Find History on YouTube (Opens in a new window), Find History on Instagram (Opens in a new window), Find History on TikTok (Opens in a new window), These Appalling Images Exposed Child Labor in America, Why the Great Steel Strike of 1919 Was One of Labor's Biggest Failures, explosive device killed more than 30 people, How Communists Became a Scapegoat for the Red Summer 'Race Riots' of 1919, https://www.history.com/news/american-labor-unions-decline-1920s. 64, No. However, plants in more heavily unionized sectors are more likely to lose jobs and grow at slower rates than plants in less heavily unionized sectors are. 34-53. 44, No. 37, No. Estimates the effects of unions on wages in Canada, explicitly correcting for measurement errors. 117-132. On his inauguration, Trump has the opportunity to appoint two new members to the National Labor Relations Board now controlled by Obama appointees with administrative discretion to implement pro-labor decisions. Something Doesnt Add Up. 4 (August 2004), pp. 510-527. Union wage gains do not materialize out of thin air. Lemieux, Thomas, "Estimating the Effects of Unions on Wage Inequality in a Panel Data Model with Comparative Advantage and Nonrandom Selection," Journal of Labor Economics , Vol. Then there's Henry Ford, who changed everything. For much of the 20th century, things were different. Empirical data on publicly traded firms between 1970 and 1976 support the theory. 426-451. In other words, his unlikely victory follows a straight line from the defeat of the Labor Reform Act of 1978 to the election of 2016. They are cartels that work by keeping employment down to raise wages for their members. In the past few decades, the number of union workers has shrunk. When we look at the typical lobby, concluded three leading political scientists in their 1963 study, American Business and Public Policy, we find its opportunities to maneuver are sharply limited, its staff mediocre, and its typical problem not the influencing of Congressional votes but finding the clients and contributors to enable it to survive at all.. The poverty of Appalachia can be traced to the mineworkers' union. Consequently, unions do not raise wages in many newly organized companies. A&P Supermarket disappeared in 2015 after more than 100 years in business as it could not compete with cheaper grocers like Walmart or higher-end chains like Whole Foods. Unions benefit their members but hurt consumers generally, and especially workers who are denied job opportunities. Non-union manufacturing employment increased by 6 percent over that time. But the ads do not represent InBev its stated or implied commitments in any detectable way. Non-union refers to workers not covered by collective bargaining agreements. There is no definitive list of companies unions have destroyed, as the impact of unions on businesses is highly contested and difficult to measure. They come out of business earnings. Unions," by Emin M. Dinlersoz and Jeremy Greenwood. 3 (June 1979), pp. In 2020, an estimated 14.3 million workers (or just under 11% of the workforce) in the U.S. were members of labor unions. The labor unions which have driven the makers of Twinkies into bankruptcy, potentially destroying 18,500 jobs, could have learned a lot from that old children's fairy tale. Reduced investment harms unionized companies in the long term, and jobs gradually shift to non-union firms that invest more. 58, No. That is why the federal anti-trust laws exempt labor unions; otherwise, anti-monopoly statutes would also prohibit union activity. And very few companies had their own Washington lobbyists prior to the 1970s. What Unions Do: How Labor Unions Affect Jobs and the Economy, What Is Happening in This Unprecedented U.S. Labor Market? 117-132; Barry T. Hirsch, "Firm Investment Behavior and Collective Bargaining Strategy," Industrial Relations, Vol. Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker doesn't like unions, and unions don't like him. 58, No. The steel and auto The biggest effect on this once-great industry was in the early years. 69, No. April 2023 Update. Trumps plan meshes perfectly with the ideology of right to work, which promotes itself as a tool of development and economic advancement, even though recent evidence shows the claim is dubious. This pattern holds across many industries: Between new companies starting up and existing companies expanding, non-union jobs grow by roughly 3 percent each year, while 3 percent of union jobs disappear. It will still exist and employ union members--but tens of thousands of UAW members have lost their jobs. Their gambit paid off in November when a federal appeals court upheld the validity of a county right-to-work law. For more information, please see our But with these higher wages, unions bring less investment, fewer jobs, higher prices, and smaller 401(k) plans for everyone else. 691-703. Uses CPS data from 1973 to 1986 to examine changes in the union wage premium and union employment. Description: Construction-industry painters, Description: United States Postal Service (USPS) mail delivery workers in rural areas, Description: Mass transit, railroad and airline workers, Description: Entertainment (theater, motion picture and television production, trade shows, television broadcasting and concerts), Description: Professional association for registered nurses, Description: Mass transit service workers, Description: Construction-industry sheet metal workers; also shipbuilders, engineers, conductors, welders and more, Description: USPS workers other than letter carriers, Description: Actors, recording artists and broadcasters, Find Out: How Much the US Minimum Wage Has Changed Since the Year You Were Born, Description: USPS mail delivery workers in urban areas, Description: Textile and garment manufacturing workers; hotel, restaurant and gaming workers; transportation workers, Description: Municipal firefighters and paramedics, Description: Miscellaneous U.S. federal government workers, Description: Journeymen and apprentices of the plumbing, pipe fitting and sprinkler fitting industry, Description: Operators of construction equipment; stationary engineers, Description: Automobile, truck, aerospace, farm equipment and construction equipment manufacturing workers and more, Read: What You Can Rent on a Minimum Wage Salary in Every State, Description: Building industry carpenters, Description: Miscellaneous construction workers; aircraft workers and more, Description: Steel mill workers; related trades, Description: Telecommunication, customer service, broadcasting, public sector, healthcare and other workers, Description: Electrical manufacturing workers; electric utility workers, Description: Retail store and distribution employees, Did You Know? [14]Barry T. Hirsch and Edward J. Schumacher, "Unions, Wages, and Skills," Journal of Human Resources, Vol. But sometime around 2000, industry lobbyists dreamed up the bold idea of proposing and supporting what became Medicare Part Da prescription drug benefit, but one which explicitly forbade bulk purchasingan estimated $205 billion benefit to companies over a 10-year period. 3 (Summer 2007), pp. Firms that move from having 20 percent of their workers belonging to unions to 50 percent decrease R&D spending by 40 percent relative to average R&D spending levels. Other union policies, such as union work rules designed to increase the number of workers needed to do a job and stringent job classifications, also raise costs. Unions redistribute wealth between workers. For much of the 20th century, things were different. Leonard, Jonathan S., "Unions and Employment Growth," Industrial Relations, Vol. 1 (Winter 1992), pp. [33] That study, however--prominently cited by labor advocates--essentially found that unions have no effect on the workplace. Unless the labor movement wants to concede that unions do not raise wages, it cannot use this research to argue that unions do not cost jobs. Labor unions were in the middle of "Operation Dixie," a campaign to organize the non-unionized textile 52, No. This post appears courtesy of New America's Weekly Wonk magazine. [15]Thomas Lemieux, "Estimating the Effects of Unions on Wage Inequality in a Panel Data Model with Comparative Advantage and Nonrandom Selection," Journal of Labor Economics, Vol. Extends the research of Card, "The Effect of Unions on the Structure of Wages: A Longitudinal Analysis." They argue that the bill will make it easier for unions to organize workers. 783-807. Unions do not have the same effect at all companies. 1 (February 1991), pp. Anti-union sentiment in manufacturing has contributed to the steady decline of organized labor. Krol, Robert, and Shirley Svorny, "Unions and Employment Growth: Evidence from State Economic Recoveries," Journal of Labor Research, Vol. Union membership now bobs around 12 percent of the workforce. Employment growth falls by 35 percent. One prominent study comparing workers who voted narrowly for unionizing with those who voted narrowly against unionizing came to the opposite conclusion, finding that newly organized companies were no more likely to shed jobs or go out of business. 31, No. Finds that union members earn between 12 percent and 14 percent more than non-union members after controlling for other observable factors such as experience and education. [18]David Lee and Alexandre Mas, "Long-Run Impacts of Unions on Firms: New Evidence from Financial Markets, 1961-1999," National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper No. Consequently, unionized companies spend 20 percent less on physical capital and 30 percent less on R&D. [1] This legislation replaces traditional secret-ballot organizing elections with publicly signed cards, allowing union organizers to pressure and harass workers into joining a union. Consequently, unions negotiate contracts that allow firms to lay off newer hires and keep pay high for senior members instead of contracts that lower wages for all workers and preserve jobs.[31]. 785-806. These studies come to the surprising conclusion that forming a union does not raise workers' wages. Here Are the 50 Lowest-Paying Jobs in America, Description: Employees of state, county and municipal governments, Description: Truck drivers, warehouse workers and other trades, Description: Public school teachers, registered nurses (RNs), professional, technical and nonprofessional healthcare workers, Description: Hotel, restaurant and hospitality workers; RNs, professional, technical and nonprofessional healthcare workers; public employees, Description: Public school employees including but not limited to teachers, education support professionals, cafeteria workers, bus drivers, guidance counselors, nurses, administrative assistants, secretaries, psychologists and librarians, 44 Ways To Trim Your Living Expenses During the Coronavirus Quarantine, 94 Money-Making Skills You Can Learn in Less Than a Year, 24 Ways To Maximize Your Paycheck This Year, How Long $1 Million in Savings Will Last in Every State. Things are quite different today. 1 (January 1998), pp. Uses CPS data from 1987-1988 to examine the differences between estimates of the average earnings of union and non-union workers and the wage gains to individual workers who join and leave union jobs. As research fellow in labor economics at The Heritage Foundation, James Sherk researched ways to promote competition and mobility. Uses NLSY data to estimate wage changes for workers who join and leave unions. In one spot, the king enters a tavern and orders Bud Lights for everyone, eliciting cries of approval from the assembled crowd. It is difficult to reconcile these studies with the large body of other research showing that union members earn more than non-union members, or with the strong evidence that unions reduce profits. Mr. Walther is the editor of The Lamp, a Catholic literary journal, and a contributing Opinion writer. And heres our email: letters@nytimes.com. Such studies look at the same workers and same plants over time, thereby controlling for many unmeasured effects. The vast majority of manufacturing jobs lost over the past three decades have been among union members--non-union manufacturing employment has risen. In essence, unions "tax" investments that corporations make, redistributing part of the return from these investments to their members. Most studies find that jobs drop at newly organized companies, with employment falling between 5 percent and 10 percent.[32]. and our [2] The official case for EFCA rests on the argument that greater union membership benefits the economy. Stripped of wartime protections and branded as anti-American, labor unions languished in the Roaring Twenties. Unionized construction jobs fell by 17 percent. New York CNN . Monthly Jobs Report Still Reliable or the Last Domino To Fall? Also shows that non-union employment in those sectors has held steady. 18, No. 44, No. 1383-1441. Today, unions have been swept into dusty corners of the U.S. workforce, such as Las Vegas casino cleaners and New York City hotel staff. 16, No. 354-367. Wachter, Michael, "Theories of the Employment Relationship: Choosing Between Norms and Contracts," in Theoretical Perspectives on Work and the Employment Relationship, ed. READ MORE: Minimum Wage in America: A Timeline. [24], Other industries experienced similar shifts. If General Motors had invested successfully in producing an inexpensive electric car, and if sales of that new vehicle had made GM profitable, then the UAW would not have agreed to any concessions. After the union tax, R&D investments earn lower returns for GM than for its non-union competitors such as Toyota and Honda. 2 (September 2001), pp. Both of these effects cause unionized firms to cut investment in physical capital by 13 percent and investment in R&D by 15 percent to 20 percent. 1 (October 1982), pp. The automakers also hire fewer workers because they now make and sell fewer cars. As consumers have voted with their feet, the Detroit automakers have been brought to the brink of bankruptcy. That includes the first location in Seattle, the company's hometown, which voted unanimously in March. Freeman, Richard B., and Morris M. Kleiner, "Do Unions Make Enterprises Insolvent?" [15] Just as the land surrounding Silicon Valley does not itself raise wages, most of the difference between union and non-union wages has little or nothing to do with unions themselves. Also finds that unions negotiate contracts that reduce the returns to individual skills and ability, such as seniority pay instead of merit pay. First, it caused the loss of some 700,000 jobs as production moved to Mexico. Connolly, Robert, Barry T. Hirsch, and Mark Hirschey, "Union Rent Seeking, Intangible Capital, and Market Value of the Firm," Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol. Republicans in the past election won a legislative trifecta in the states of Missouri, Kentucky, Ohio and New Hampshire. Consequently, unions do not negotiate higher wages for many newly organized workers. Hirsch, Barry T., "Sluggish Institutions in a Dynamic World: Can Unions and Industrial Competition Coexist?" more than the $2 billion we spend to fund the House ($1.18 billion) and Senate ($860 million). Read This Before Shopping for Your Bud Light Replacement Beer. Freeman, Richard B., and Morris M. Kleiner, "The Impact of New Unionization on Wages and Working Conditions," Journal of Labor Economics, Vol. Then they would need--and hire--fewer workers. 2 (April 1998), pp. As a result, union coverage fell from 38 percent to 16 percent of all construction workers between 1977 and 2008.[25]. 176, No. Finds that workers who vote to join a union do win certification but that unions have essentially no effect on the firm or the workers. Presents both theory and empirical evidence on the effect of unions on investment. 8: Canadian & Mexican Auto Industries and Unions A: Canada Bruce Allen, Manufacturing a crisis: Organized Labour and the Canadian Auto Industry, Briarpatch, August 1, 2008, available here. These commercials no doubt served as a winking affirmation of what some Bud Light customers perceive as their anti-elitist worldview. Some unions win higher wages for their members, though many do not. 34, No. Before the current downturn, the UAW routinely went on strike unless the Detroit automakers paid what they demanded-- until recently, $70 an hour in wages and benefits. Supporters defend EFCA by sidestepping concerns about taking away workers' right to vote. The evolution of business lobbying from a sparse reactive force into a ubiquitous and increasingly proactive one is among the most important transformations in American politics over the last 40 years. Probing the history of this transformation reveals that there is no normal level of business lobbying in American democracy. Economic research shows exactly this: Over the long term, unionized jobs disappear. As one company lobbyist I interviewed for my new book, The Business of America Is Lobbying, told me, When I started [in 1983], people didnt really understand government affairs. Golf's Greatest Holes: Golfing legend Paul McGinley takes television presenter Chris Hollins on a tour of the best golf courses in Ireland and Northern Ireland. Less investment makes unionized companies less competitive, and they gradually shrink. Unpasteurized, lacking preservatives and unavailable in Eastern states, Coors was alternately regarded as raffish and dclass, promoted by cowboy stars and denounced by the gay rights leader Harvey Milk. In addition to Bud Light, InBev owns Corona, Stella Artois, Michelob, Becks, Modelo and many other beer brands. 691-703. In the second half of the 20th century, the information age did a few things that badly hurt unions. Of the 100 organizations that spend the most on lobbying, 95 consistently represent business. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Critics point to the collapse of many highly unionized domestic industries and argue that unions harm the economy. Large corporations had largely sat by idly, unsure of what to do. Unionized companies are no more likely to go out of business than are non-union firms. The Times is committed to publishing a diversity of letters to the editor. WebCompanies such as Amazon and Trader Joe's have avoided dealing with labor unions, but workers are beginning to organize. 95-121. 2023 Reddit, Inc. All rights reserved. 459-485. 66, No. To make the sell, lobbyists had to go against the long-entrenched notion in corporate boardrooms that politics was a necessary evil to be avoided if possible. Unions destroyed the steel industry in the U.S. 3 (Summer 2007), pp. Hirsch, Barry T., "Union Coverage and Profitability Among U.S. Firms," The Review of Economics and Statistics , Vol. 1 Although union workers still make higher wages, depleted pension funds, as well as high Few Australian unions have been fully transformed and it is important not to understate the magnitude of changes now demanded of them. "When the demand for unskilled labor rises there is a larger payoff to unionizing it," the authors contend. 2691, March 2007; John Abowd and Henry Farber, "Job Queues and the Union Status of Workers," Industrial and Labor Relations Review, Vol. They are labor cartels, intentionally reducing the number of jobs to drive up wages for their members. 1 (Winter 1992), pp. 41-42 (January-June 1996), pp. 5 (October 1991), pp. 65-83; Peter D. Linneman, Michael L. Wachter, and William H. Carter, "Evaluating the Evidence on Union Employment and Wages," Industrial and Labor Relations Review, Vol. Kang, Changhui, "Union Wage Effect: New Evidence from Matched Employer-Employee Data," National University of Singapore, Department of Economics, Departmental Working Paper No. 1 (February 1991), pp. This has happened to the UAW. READ MORE: Why the Great Steel Strike of 1919 Was One of Labor's Biggest Failures, WATCH:The Red Scare Started Before the McCarthy Era. ?abstract_id=1353305 (May 4, 2009). As a result, collective bargaining coverage fell from 38 percent of manufacturing workers to 12 percent over those years. The UAW accepted steep job losses as the price of keeping wages high for senior members. But it would take time for them to become fully convinced. Some of them are among the most powerful unions in the nation and have led strikes that changed America. Reuters/Mike Segar How we got here. Unions a failed experiment in Socialism where the best worker eventually becomes no better than the worst worker. 56, No. Unions argue that they get workers their "fair share," while employers complain that union contracts make them uncompetitive. Of all the responses to the Mulvaney affair, the most clueless was an advertisement for something called Ultra Right Beer, an astonishingly expensive alternative to Bud Light $20 for a six-pack that bills itself as 100 percent woke-free beer for people who know which restroom to use. On its website, the purveyors of Ultra Right urge customers to cease giving money to companies who hate our values. But in our homogenized corporate culture, all major companies hate the ostensible values espoused by the creators of Ultra Right or are completely indifferent to them. 261-291. 2 (April 2004), pp. [24]Barry T. Hirsch and David A. Macpherson, "Union Membership and Coverage Database from the Current Population Survey," Industrial Labor Relations Review, Vol. Examines the relationship between unionization and R&D, using industry-level data from Canada. Since then, at least 15 other Starbucks sites have followed suit. These studies typically find that the average union member earns roughly 15 percent more than comparable non-union workers. Wed like to hear what you think about this or any of our articles. Webare western hognose snakes legal in the uk risk assessment for cleaning pigeon droppings It turned workers into specialized cogs. In 1900, just 7 percent of Americans were union members. But if you see something that doesn't look right, click here to contact us! [12]George Jakubson, "Estimation and Testing of the Union Wage Effect Using Panel Data," Review of Economic Studies, Vol. Theoretically, once a company makes an investment, the union has the power to "tax" it by demanding higher wages paid for by the returns to that investment. 153-176. I found a good one in "The Rise and Fall of U.S. 3 (July 1999), pp. Write an article and join a growing community of more than 163,400 academics and researchers from 4,609 institutions. 971-991. Unions function as labor cartels. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising.
Bbc Wiltshire Sport,
Special Olympics Dream House Raffle 2021,
What Happened To Reverend Alden's Wife,
Live Border Cameras El Paso,
Articles L